| Sponsor | Title/Type |
Description | Prizes/Incentives | Evaluation |
Alliance
for Young Artists & Writers*
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
*A not-for-profit group sponsored by Alex. Brown & Sons, Inc., Binney &
Smith, The Cooper Union Center for Design & Typography, Goldman, Sachs
& Co., The Hallmark Corporate Foundation, The John F. Kennedy Center for
the Performing Arts, The New York Times Community Affairs Department,
The M.R. Robinson Fund, Scholastic Inc., and Strathmore Paper Company
|
Scholastic
Art & Writing Awards/ Alliance for Young Artists &
Writers
ART & WRITING MULTIMEDIA CONTEST
|
An
annual event open to all U.S. and Canadian students in grades 7-12. Kids
create original artwork or writing in about 2 dozen categories. High school
seniors may submit a portfolio of their work. Approximately 250,000 entries are
received each year.
|
Various
prizes in Junior and Senior Divisions, including $5,000 college scholarships.
|
Not
commercial. Sponsors are named but no products are pushed.
|
Almond
Board of California
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
|
Almond
Angel Awards Contest
WRITING/ IDEA CONTEST
|
A
national contest for students in grades K-9. Students are asked to write a
"little idea that can make the world a lot better" in one page or less.
A drawing of the idea is encouraged, but not required.
|
10
winners (5 in grades K-4; 5 in grades 5-9) with one adult each to be flown to
Washington, D.C. in the spring of 1995, where a Grand Prize idea will be
chosen. Grand Prize Winner gets a $1,000 savings bond; winner and his/her
teacher each get a computer. Grand Prize winner's school receives $500. Other
first-place winners each receive a $500 savings bond. All 10 winners and their
teachers receive a learning software library. Each participating classroom
receives California Almond Snack Packs. The Almond Board will donate up to
$100,000 to make the Grand Prize Winner's idea come true.
|
Commercial.
The sponsor's product is part of the title and is identified with the contest.
Sponsor's product is also involved with the prizes. The Almond Board logo
appears on the poster and the letter to the family and the Board takes several
opportunities to push the eating of almonds. In the letter to the family, which
spells out the contest rules, the Almond Board explains, "We're not looking for
a complex answer to a world problem -- just a little idea that can add a lot to
our lives. Just like little almonds add a lot to the foods we enjoy every day."
In addition, the Board offers some "little ideas" for some nutritious snacks --
and, not surprisingly, each includes almonds.
|
American
Express
|
Our
Earth Didn't Come With Instructions (Fortunately That's Half The
Fun)
GEOGRAPHY CONTEST
|
Annual
contest for grades 6-12 in which individual students or student groups examine
a geographic issue or problem of their choice concerning travel and trade,
cultural diversity, or the environment. Using maps, surveys, interviews,
charts, and graphs, they collect and analyze data, draw conclusions, and submit
their completed project.
|
"First,
Second, and Third Prize projects get $7,500, $5,000, and $2,500 respectively.
The winners and three National Finalists from each category also win a
Goode's World Atlas compliments of Rand McNally."
|
Low
commercialism. American Express does not push its card or travel services.
Entries not part of any publicity campaign, and prizes are checks from American
Express. One category of contest is "Travel & Trade," where contest rules
suggest that "Projects in this Category look at how travel and trade influence
the geography of a place or region--or vice versa. They also can examine how
the global market or tourism affects a specific place" but nothing
sponsor-specific is mentioned.
|
AT&T
Bell Labs
|
Personal
Communicator Contest
SCIENCE/ TECHNOLOGY CONTEST
|
One-time
contest ran in conjunction with a TV program. Targeted audience was 5th- to
10th-graders, but open to all students. Students designed futuristic ways of
communicating with each other.
|
Winning
design shown on TV program. Winners' class talked with sponsor's vice president
via two-way video link. Second prize was his book.
|
Commercial.
Contest had direct tie-in to TV show, which was, in essence, an infomercial for
AT&T. Prizes were books by AT&T scientists and conversations with the
same using AT&T technology.
|
BIC
Corporation
Developed by Lifetime Learning Systems
|
Getting
on the Right Wavelength
WRITING CONTEST
|
Annual
essay-writing contest included as part of a sponsored creative writing program.
Open to all 11th- and 12th-graders in the U.S. Students write 200-word essay,
"If I Could Have One Wish." Invitation to participate included in BIC's SEM of
the same name (see page 56).
|
Grand
prize winner receives laptop computer with word processing software (valued at
$3,000); other prizes range from $500 and $100 in cash.
|
Commercial.
Entrants must sign an affidavit allowing their names to be used by the sponsor
for publicity purposes. Sponsor's name and logo are not part of the entry form,
and product is not directly hyped, but The Right Wavelength refers to a
larger publicity campaign, which includes a highly commercial SEM.
|
California
Table Grape Commission
|
Project
Environment Contest
WRITING AND ART CONTEST
|
Annual
essay and poster contest in which students in grades 4-6 "can express their
views on nature." They can "address concepts such as what nature is, where we
can find nature, and what we can do to improve our natural environment."
|
National
Grand Prize and four regional first, second, and third place prizes. National
Grand Prize is $500 and a mountain bike and helmet; first prize is mountain
bike and helmet; second prize is binoculars or dome tent; third prize is a
camera or a sleeping bag.
|
Commercial.
Sponsor's name and logo on poster, teacher materials, and student materials.
No purchase of products or hyping of products involved with contest, but
entrants become part of publicity campaign. Contest seems to promote the eating
of grapes.
|
Delta
Air Lines
with WGBH, Boston and WQED Communications
|
Delta's
World Adventure Challenge with Carmen Sandiego
GEOGRAPHY/ WRITING CONTEST
|
An
international geography essay contest based on the popular PBS TV series
Where in the World is Carmen Sandiego? Contest challenges students in
grades 4-7 to 1) choose and describe something important from their town or
city that Carmen's gang might steal (the loot) and how the theft affects the
town, 2) choose and describe a city where the loot was taken by Carmen's gang
and what happened when the city got the loot, 3) describe how they followed the
crooks to the new city (the route) and recovered the loot. Students must create
two maps or drawings that help describe the action. Contest ends March 1, 1995.
|
Prizes
for students and teachers: a trip aboard Delta to New York City to see a taping
of the TV show; "gift packs" including a savings bond, software, games, toys;
grand prize student winner gets trip for four to "any of Delta's worldwide
destinations."
|
Commercial.
Sponsor's product involved with prizes. Delta is hyped (as the "official
airline for kids") and if entrants are not familiar with the Carmen
Sandiego TV series they will be lost. Contest obviously good publicity for
Delta. The corporate name and logo appear on all materials. Sponsor's contest
ad tells teachers they will "receive a travel coupon good for a discounted
flight on Delta" when they call to request an entry form for the contest.
Promotional value to sponsor of contest high.
|
Discover
Credit Corp.
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
|
Your
Band, Your Plan Sweepstakes
BUSINESS/ ECONOMICS CONTEST
|
Contest
open to all kids in grades 9-12, but entry forms can only be obtained from
Scholastic magazines. Kids challenged to create a plan or plans for forming and
marketing an imaginary musical band.
|
Contestants
can complete one of five plans and be in the running for a $1,000 cash prize
plus 100 T-shirt prizes; if they complete all five plans, they're in the
running for the grand prize of $1,000 in cash plus $1,000 in gift certificates
from their favorite record or stereo store.
|
Commercial.
Student entries become part of publicity campaign. Sponsor's name/logo used for
more than title (prominent on all materials promoting contest), though product
not hyped. More than small amount of advertising for sponsor on materials.
|
Discover
Credit Corp.
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
|
Be
a Sports Entrepreneur
BUSINESS/ ECONOMICS CONTEST
|
Students
were asked to plan a sports tournament, decide on the sponsors and resources
needed to put it on, and write letters enlisting help from the sponsors. They
could work alone or in teams of up to 3 members. Contest information came as an
insert in Scholastic's magazine, Choices (10/94) and was part of a "real
world" teaching unit. Contest rules told students to "list any Scholastic
magazines you use in class."
|
Each
member of the winning team got $1,000. Teachers were eligible to "receive free
software," Scholastic magazines, time on Scholastic's on-line computer network,
or "$100 worth of books or magazines."
|
Low
commercialism. Sponsor's name used in title of program, not title of contest.
Logo not used at all on contest piece, discreetly placed on SEM cover. No
product hyped. Entrants work not part of publicity campaign.
|
Du
Pont
with General Learning Corporation and National Science Teachers Association
(NSTA)
|
Du
Pont Challenge: Science Essay Awards Program
SCIENCE/ WRITING CONTEST
|
Annual
contest in which students are challenged "to create an essay describing a
significant challenge in science." Wide range of subject areas. Open to all
U.S. and Canadian students in grades 7-9 (Junior Division) and 10-12 (Senior
Division).
|
Cash
prizes from $1,500 to $50. First-place winners, one parent, and their science
teacher are rewarded "with an all-expenses-paid VIP trip to Space Center
Houston."
|
Low
commercialism. No mention of sponsor's products on any materials. No use of
entries for publicity purposes. Sponsor's logo appears on poster and name is
used in more than title.
|
Duracell
with National Science Teachers Association (NSTA)
|
Duracell/NSTA
Scholarship Competition
SCIENCE CONTEST
|
Annual
competition for kids in grades 9-12. Kids design and build a battery-powered
device that can "educate, entertain, or make life easier in some way," submit
an essay, wiring diagram, and photo of their device. They exhibit and
demonstrate their devices at NSTA's annual convention. 100 winners each year.
|
Prizes
range from $20,000 to $100 in U.S. Savings Bonds. Sponsoring teachers can win
computers, NSTA publications, and Duracell gifts. First- and second-place
winners, their families, and their science teachers are Duracell's guests at an
awards ceremony.
|
Commercial.
Sponsor's products not involved with prizes, but are required of entries
(devices must run on Duracell batteries). Entries are used for publicity
purposes-- contest rules state that winners must attend awards ceremony in
order to receive their savings bonds.
|
Edison
Electric Institute
with The Max McGraw Foundation and the National Science Supervisors Association
(NSSA)
|
Thomas
Edison/Max McGraw Scholarship Program
SCIENCE CONTEST
|
Annual
scholarship contest. "Open to all students in grades 7-12 with an interest in
science and/or engineering." Students write proposals of 1,000 words or less
about "a completed experiment or a projected idea which would have
practical application in the fields of science and/or engineering."
|
Prizes
include $6,000 and $3,000 scholarships, trips to Chicago for the final
judging, and awards of $1,500-$750.
|
Not
commercial. No corporate sponsor or product identified, no hidden promotions
for energy community involved.
|
General
Motors
Developed by Lifetime Learning Systems
|
"Baseball,
Me, My Family & Friends" Student Essay Contest
WRITING CONTEST
|
One-time
contest open to students in grades 5-7. Kids were asked to "write a story,
poem, or essay (200 words or less) telling what baseball means to you, your
family and friends."
|
Regional
prizes included a $1,000 savings bond. Contestants also got "the chance to win
one of two college scholarship contributions from General Motors worth $10,000
at maturity."
|
Low
commercialism. No product needed to participate. GM logo on some materials, but
no GM product mentioned. Did promote PBS special which was sponsored by GM, but
didn't promote PBS. Contest was a tie-in with sponsor's 9-part PBS series about
baseball.
|
Greater
New York Savings Bank (The)
|
"Draw
Your Dream" Contest
ART CONTEST
|
Open
to "New York school children who are learning about the value of money and
[long-term] saving." Each child draws a picture that completes the statement,
"If I save a lot today, in the future I could..." Currently, 1,000 students in
22 schools in the New York City area participate. Part of SEM program "Kid's
Bank."
|
Winners
receive a $50 deposit into their "Kids' Bank" account; semi-finalists receive a
$25 deposit. All participating students receive a $1 "Kids' Bank" account at
the bank and their entries "will be displayed in local branches" of the bank."
|
Commercial.
Product is involved with prizes. Sponsor's SEM is promoted. Entries displayed
in bank branches. Contest seems to have been designed to get kids (and their
parents and teachers) into branches of The Greater New York Savings Bank and to
encourage kids to open (and add to) "Kids' Bank" accounts.
|
Johnson
Controls
with the National Energy Foundation and others
|
TEAMS
(Total Energy Action Management in Schools) Energy Policy
SCIENCE/ ENVIRONMENT CONTEST
|
Annual
school program that encourages 6th-8th graders to explore energy use and
efficiency in and around their schools. Students draft actual energy plans for
submission to a national contest.
|
Winners
receive cash prizes of up to $5,000 and local and national recognition. This
year's grand prize winners receive trips to Japan to serve as youth
representatives on the 1995 World Energy Congress Council.
|
Not
commercial. Sponsor's name used in title only. Kids not part of any publicity
campaign. Sponsor's product not identified.
|
Kudos
Brand/ Mars, Inc.
|
"Dig
Into Your Food" Contest
WRITING (Rap, Rhyme, or Song) CONTEST
|
Annual
contest in which students write a "poem, rap, or rhyme on nutrition in 50 words
or less."
|
First
prize winner receives a $500 savings bond and his/her school food service
operation receives $500 cash. One hundred runners-up will each receive a Kudos
Brand t-shirt.
|
Commercial.
Sponsor's trademark prominent on student poster and name is mentioned
frequently. Winners must release entries for publicity purposes. Sponsor's
product hyped on t-shirt prize.
|
Michael
Jordan Foundation (The) Education Club
with Sara Lee, Discover Card, Target, the Chicago Bulls, American Airlines,
and Gatorade
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
|
Michael
Jordan Foundation Education Club Contest
ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT CONTEST
|
Originally
for Chicago 6th graders, now a national program. Purpose: to inspire students
to improve academics, attendance, and community service. Invitation given
through SEM program (see page 54).
|
First
prize: a luncheon hosted by Michael Jordan and his family in Chicago.
|
Low
commercialism as contest component, part of a commercial SEM. Tone is laudatory
to Jordan, and therefore to the products he sponsors.
|
National
Geographic Society
with Amtrak
(National Geographic Society is looking for new sponsor beginning with 1995
contest.)
|
National
Geography Bee
GEOGRAPHY CONTEST
|
Annual
contest for students in grades 4-8 that encourages the study of geography.
Students take written and oral tests on both the school and state and national
levels.
|
National
prizes: $25,000-$10,000 college scholarships. State prizes: $500 each to
schools of top 10 finalists.
|
Not
commercial with qualifications. No sponsor logos or mention of sponsor's
products. National Geography Bee has own logo, Amtrak mentioned on cover of
materials only (and then only named). Prizes are scholarships with no sponsor
involvement. Sponsor is more visible at national finals which are broadcast
over PBS.
|
NYNEX
Foundation
with NSTA
|
NYNEX
Science and Technology Awards Program
SCIENCE/ TECHNOLOGY CONTEST
|
Annual
contest open to students in grades 9-12 attending school in New York and New
England. "Teams of 2-4 students must propose a solution to a public
[community] problem, using science and technology." They write a 10-12 page
essay and a one-page abstract telling how they would reduce or eliminate the
problem.
|
Top
36 teams receive prizes from $15,000 per student (first prize) to $3,000 per
student; prizes of $3,000 or more awarded over four-year period. Additional
prizes: development or implementation of solution with "seed money" from
sponsor, internships, and matching scholarships from Rensselaer Polytechnic
Institute.
|
Not
commercial with qualifications. Sponsor's name appears as part of contest
title, but no products are named or pushed (it is never even noted that NYNEX
is a phone company). However, all entries, while remaining the property of the
students, can be used by NYNEX and NSTA for promotional purposes.
|
Oxy
10/ SmithKline Beecham
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
|
Oxy
10 $10,000 Scholarship Contest
MULTIMEDIA CONTEST
|
An
annual program In 1992, gave 9th-12th graders the chance to "tell people of the
future what your generation is really all about"; in 1993, contestants
predicted the "10 major things that are going to happen in the world by the
year 2000." Entries could be written, painted, sung, videotaped, or even sewn
into a flag.
|
Prizes
ranged from $10,000 scholarship to copies of The College Survival
Handbook.
|
Highly
commercial. Requires sending UPC code from Oxy package or postcard with Oxy
written on it for entry. Sponsor's name/logo used in more than title; in
addition, winners agreed to let sponsor use their names and photos for
promotional purposes for five years. Motivation appears to have been to build
brand recognition for Oxy 10.
|
Pizza
Hut
|
BOOK
IT! Bunch Contest
WRITING CONTEST
|
Onegoing
contest which generated about 12,000 entries from kindergartners to sixth
graders nationwide. Students were asked to create a new "reading buddy" to join
four existing characters in the sponsor's National BOOK IT! Reading Incentive
Program and to write a plot for a new adventure story for them.
|
Winners'
school received $5,000 "to support its library." Teacher of winning class
received $2,500 "for personal use." Each student in the winning class received
a selection of BOOK IT! Bunch items (rulers, pencils, Frisbees).
|
Low
commercialism. All prizes had BOOK IT! name and logo on them, but no BOOK IT!
materials had Pizza Hut logo or name on them.
|
Playskool
Developed by Scholastic Inc.
|
Definitely
Dinosaurs Contest
ART CONTEST
|
One-time
contest in which first graders submitted drawings on the subject, "If Dinosaurs
Were Alive Today." Invitation inserted in Scholastic classroom magazine for
first graders; attracted 48,000 entries.
|
Highly
commercial. Clearly designed to promote Playskool's series of plastic toys
called "Definitely Dinosaurs." According to Scholastic, sponsor's objective
was "to increase awareness of Playskool's products among readers of
Scholastic's magazine for first graders."
|
Procter
& Gamble
|
Sell
Your School Contest
BUSINESS/ ECONOMICS CONTEST
|
A
marketing contest open to students in grades 9-12 who work together in teams of
"no less than seven and not more than 35 students who attend the same
school...to produce an advertisement" about their school, using the "medium
which best delivers their message to the target audience." Invitation to
participate offered as part of a teaching package on economics that sponsor
says shows "how advertising powers the whole economic chain and the jobs in
it." (See page 48.)
|
Prizes
given in three advertising categories: print, audio, and video; grand prizes of
$500, first prizes of $250, second prizes of $100.
|
Not
commercial with qualifications. The contest piece, taken alone, does not
mention sponsor or sponsor's products at all. However, entries can be used for
publicity purposes, and entrants are urged (though not required) to use
materials from the sponsor's SEM, which is highly commercial. Teacher could use
contest alone.
|
Scripps
Howard
|
Scripps
Howard National Spelling Bee
SPELLING BEE
|
Nationwide
spelling contest with participants sponsored by their hometown newspapers and
the finals in Washington sponsored by S-H. Sponsoring newspapers do not have
to be part of the S-H chain.
|
NSB
local prizes were: a Webster's 10th edition dictionary, a Random-House
dictionary, a 1993 World almanac, and an Encyclopedia Brittanica.
|
Not
commercial. Sponsor's name and logo used only as part of title, and does not
appear on student materials. S-H mentioned only in a quick blurb that is sent
to newspapers interested in sponsoring participants and to educators.
|
Sears
Optical
Developed by Lifetime Learning Systems
|
"The
Eyes Have It" Sears Optical Poster Contest
ART CONTEST
|
Took
place in the 1991-92 school year. Kids were asked to design a poster telling
why eyes are important and why we should take care of them. Adjunct of an
on-going sponsored eye-care program (see page 54).
|
Winners
received a free pair of eyeglasses. In addition, students received "special eye
examination offer."
|
Highly
commercial. Sponsor's product hyped, and entrants must visit Sears to
participate. Sponsor's product involved with prizes. Obviously designed to get
kids and their families to visit a Sears Optical store. Sponsor's name and logo
on all materials. Kids had to submit their posters to a local Sears Optical.
Winners had to return to the store to receive their prizes.
|
Toshiba
with National Science Teachers Association (NSTA)
|
Toshiba/
NSTA "ExploraVision" Awards Program
SCIENCE/ TECHNOLOGY CONTEST
|
Annual
contest in which students "select a technology . . . then project what that
technology might or could be like 20 years from now." Open to teams of three or
four students from all U.S. and Canadian schools, in four grade divisions: K-3,
4-6, 7-9, and 10-12.
|
First
prize: $10,000 for each student; smaller prizes for runners-up. Toshiba
equipment to advisors and schools of the 12 finalist teams; first- and
second-place teams and their parents, teachers, or advisors win trips to
Washington, D.C. for an awards weekend.
|
Not
commercial with qualifications. Sponsor's name appears as part of contest
title, but no products are named or pushed. Entrants must allow their entries
and their names and photos used for promotional purposes.
|
United
States Patent Model Foundation
with KMART, Crayola, Duracell International, Inc., Polaroid Corp., Good
Housekeeping, 3M Company, Dow Brands, Inc., Pepsi-Cola Company, Moore Business
Forms, Inc.
|
Invent
America! Patent Search
SCIENCE CONTEST
|
Students
in grades K-8 "develop a unique idea for an invention and turn that idea from
an abstract concept to a completed project." Kids submit drawings and written
descriptions of their inventions. Categories include the environment, leisure
time, household, special needs, humanitarian, safety, and "Rube Goldberg."
|
Prizes:
$1,000-$200 U.S. Savings Bonds.
|
Commercial.
Sponsors' products hyped, sponsors' name/logo appear frequently. Entrants
become part of publicity campaign for sponsors. Purpose of contest is to
enhance sponsors' public image; handbook kids get calls sponsors "outstanding
companies [that] put kids and education first." Student applications
contain endorsements such as "Crayola is Invent America's official
drawing and coloring sponsor" and the advertising statement "Colors make your
invention drawings come alive!"
|
Westinghouse
with Science Service, Inc.
|
Westinghouse
Science Talent Search
SCIENCE CONTEST
|
Annual
contest open to all U.S. high school seniors. Entrants submit "a written report
on an independent research project."
|
First
prize: $40,000 college scholarship; smaller awards for others.
|
Not
commercial. Sponsor's name appears in contest title, but no products are
mentioned or pushed.
|
ZIPLOC/
Dow Brands
|
ZIPLOC
National Sandwich Day Contest
FOOD CONTEST
|
Annual
contest open to students in grades 1-6. Students create original sandwich
fillings and name their creations.
|
Prizes
(one per grade) include $50 to $500 savings bonds and free trips to Los Angeles
for finalists; winners' schools receive same amount of cash for equipment.
|
Highly
commercial. Sponsor's name and trademarked character incorporated into title
and contest logo. Sponsor's product hyped. Entries used in sponsor's
promotion. The use of ZIPLOC bags is suggested in sponsor's educational packet.
Obviously designed to promote ZIPLOC sandwich bags.
|