Consumers Union estimates that last year,
approximately 238,500 of the personal computers sold in the U.S. were
"lemons." These computers had to have three of more components
replaced. This estimate is based on data from a survey of more than
54,000 Consumer Reports readers. See "Lemon
Aid for PCs Gone Sour" Consumer
Reports, November 2000, page 8.
According to the consumer survey results, as
reported in Consumer Reports, 5% of desktop PCs sold since
1996 were "dead on arrival." An additional 11% of PCs had serious
problems within the first month of ownership.
State legislatures in Pennsylvania and Illinois
have considered bills to create a "lemon law" for computers. Like the
lemon laws for cars, these bills would give consumers a statutory
right to a refund or a replacement for hard to fix computers. The
consumer's right to chose a refund or replacement would be triggered
by two unsuccessful repair attempts.
For the Consumer Reports article and for
more information about these innovative state law proposals, see:
www.consumerreports.org
The Illinois bill text: www.legis.state.il.us/legisnet/legisnet91/hbgroups/hb/910HB4122LV.html
For the Pennsylvania bill analysis: click here
Prepared by:
Gail Hillebrand
West
Coast Regional Office
Consumers Union of U.S., Inc.
1535 Mission St.
San Francisco, CA 94103