Consumers Union

 

Potential Public Health Impacts Of The Use Of Recombinant Bovine Somatotropin In Dairy Production

 

Table 1. Results from eight studies on the levels of IGF-1 in milk from rbGH-treated and untreated cows.

Company
Author, Year of Publication
Sample size (# of cows)
rbGH dosage (Amount, duration)
Equivalent dose (mg/14 day period
Length of experiment (days)
IGF-1 levels in milk increased

American Cyanimid

Schingoethe & Cleale, 1989
20
10.3 mg/14 day
144
113
N

Elanco

Schames & Karg, 1988
8
640 mg/28 days
320
118
Y

Elanco

Davis et. al, 1989
36
320 mg or 640 mg/28 days
160 or 320
30
N

Elanco

Coleman et. al, 1990
12
640 mg/28 days
320
56
N

Monsanto

FDA, 1993
18
500 mg/14 days
500
42
Y

Monsanto

Torkelson et. al, 1988
18
500 mg/14 days
500
42
Y

Monsanto

White et al., 1969
18
500 mg/14 days
500
42
Y

Monsanto

Miller, et. al, 1989
64
500 mg/14 days
500
140
Y
 

 Table 2. Effect of POSILAC on mastitis. Data from Kronfeld, 1997.

Period and parity
Mastitis cases/100 cows/252 days
Significance
(p value)
Control
Posilac

Pre-approval
8 trials, 487 cows

...Primiparous

21
37
0.015

...Multiparous

36
54
0.0021

...All

32
49
0.0001

*PAMP
28 trials, 1128 cows

...Primiparous

27
33
0.17

...Multiparous

44
59
0.0001

...All

37
49
0.0001

*Post-approval monitoring program

 

Return to Report >>>

Part 1 - Report
Part 1b - Report Continued
Part 2 - References
Part 3 - Tables

©1998-2006 Consumers Union